Main Menu
Join Undercurrent on Facebook

The Private, Exclusive Guide for Serious Divers Since 1975 | |
For Divers since 1975
The Private, Exclusive Guide for Serious Divers Since 1975
Join Undercurrent on Facebook
"Best of the Web: scuba tips no other
source dares to publish" -- Forbes
July 2009    Download the Entire Issue (PDF) Available to the Public Vol. 24, No. 7   RSS Feed for Undercurrent Issues
What's this?

Death of a Shark Diver, Redux

dive ops rely on sharks for business, but it comes at a price

from the July, 2009 issue of Undercurrent   Subscribe Now

Shark attacks are happening less often. Thats according to George Burgess, curator of the International Shark Attack File. He reports 59 unprovoked attacks by sharks last year, lower than the 71 in 2007 and the all-time high of 79 in 2000. Four of those were fatal. The majority of attacks were in North American waters, 42 last year, with Florida accounting for 32 of them. Luckily, snorkelers and divers were the smallest group affected, totaling only 8 percent of unprovoked attacks.

But thats unprovoked, mind you. Burgess classifies provoked attacks as a human initiating physical contact with a shark, usually involving fishers, spearfishers and those feeding sharks. The latter is often what affects divers most as more of them go on shark dives, with boat crew chumming the waters to get sharks in front of the paying customers and that can be an accident waiting to happen. Burgess says 19 provoked attacks happened last year.

One of them was Markus Groh, an Austrian diver who died on a shark dive trip in the Bahamas with Jim Abernethys Scuba Adventures. Groh, 49, was bitten by a bull shark, which apparently mistook his calf for the baitbox that the dive operator puts at the bottom to attract sharks. We did an extensive report on Grohs death in our April 2008 issue.

Comparing Sharks to Birds and Dogs

Abernethy wasnt talking to the press then but now that there is no threat of a lawsuit, he was willing to talk to Undercurrent. He was cleared of wrongful doing by the Miami-Dade County police 24 hours after the event, and Abernethy, based in Riviera Beach, FL, says he has no plans to change anything about his shark trips, and he is backed by big names in marine biology and underwater photography. I have a two-hour plus briefing on what needs to be done when in the vicinity of large sharks, and I require the same level of advanced diver or above to dive with us. What happened was an accident that unfortunately happened on my boat. The main reason why I havent changed anything is because sharks dont eat people. Sharks do not seek them out, Ive never seen a shark being aggressive toward people. The accident with Groh, it was just not a shark attack. The Bahamas Diving Association, whose members offer openwater dives with more sedate reef sharks, has been trying for some time to get Abernethy to stop his openwater, non-caging dives but he refuses. [Cage diving] doesnt follow the way I interact with sharks.

Critics of Abernethys interactions dont like the idea of turning sharks into trained animals used to humans in the water and being fed. Abernethy replies that he looks at sharks as the Audubon Society looks at birds. Theyve been selling bird feeders for years and birdwatchers feed birds but every now and then, a bird will bite a person as a mistake. However, feeding the birds is an opportunity for people to get close to these animals so they can see them.

Then he tries another comparison: canines. Sharks are very much like dogs. There are the smaller, speedier ones, like the little dogs that nip and yap. Then there are the big dogs, walking tentatively into the living room trying not to break anything. We see that mix on our Bahamas dives.

Its the Humans Fault, Not the Sharks

That comparison to household pets is what bothers Burgess, who instead compares feeding sharks to feeding bears in parks. Encountering humans is an unusual event for sharks, so theres a natural distance, he told Undercurrent. Once that natural behavior is modified, its lost and thats where problems begin. Dive operators want to keep a lot of sharks in one place for predictability and for paying customers. But divers are seeing an underwater Disneyland rather than a natural world.

If people want to go diving with sharks, thats their choice. To me, the biggest concern is what happens when you attract sharks to the boat and how it affects their behavior, the reef ecology and the long-term affects to the shark-human relationship. If youre going to put people and food in the water to attract sharks, fine. But if something happens, its the humans fault, not the sharks.

If you want to dive, you go with a dive operator but if you want to dive with sharks, you go and learn with a shark expert. Thats Erich Ritter, who calls himself the only professional shark-human interaction specialist. He runs SharkSchool.org, an organization that teaches one-week courses in the Bahamas, Maldives and the Red Sea for divers about how to interact with sharks. Two-hour classroom sessions and homework are mixed with dives to show students how to learn sharks body language and react correctly with their own. If you can understand why a shark of any species comes closer, you are in the drivers seat and in charge of the situation. If you dont understand, you get afraid. We put divers in different scenarios and mentally push them to a point where they must rationalize the situation theyre in.

This seems rich coming from a man who is a pariah in the dive industry. Ritter, who claims a Ph.D. in behavioral ecology from the University of Zurich, says he can intuit shark behavior and read their thoughts just by looking at them. However, Ritter was bitten in the calf, just like Groh, while being filmed for Discovery Channels Shark Week series in Walkers Cay back in 2002. Ritter was demonstrating how he could, by controlling his heartbeat, interact safely with a school of sharks, even when food was in the water. But when there were more sharks than usual in the feeding area, dive staffers tried to lure them away from Ritter by throwing a piece of fish into the water 15 feet away from him. A bull shark lunged for it and in doing so, bit directly into Ritters left calf. The shinbone was so damaged that Ritters left foot must be permanently supported by a bar. Ritter blames the spotter assigned to keep an eye on the sharks and steer them away but says, My bite was the best proof that I know what Im doing.

Dive Operators Should Get Educated

Despite his reputation and claims of intuiting shark behavior, Ritter does have some good tips for improving the safety of shark dives. So we must educate the operators and have them use solid techniques. Dont have a floating milk crate for sharks to push around, attach it to the bottom and dont let divers get too close to these sharks. And always have a second dive guide who is capable of observing sharks swim patterns. If they get excited, theyll change their swim pattern. For example, if one does a wide-angle approach, it may be a little nervous but not aggressive. If it does a frontal approach, it wants to check you out and get a reaction from you. Dive operators are generally novices and have no clue to the actual behavior of these animals. They should get educated and the standards should be changed. You cant take the dive shop owners livelihood away but he can indeed change what he cant control.

Their feeding methods are debatable but shark dive operators know what their livelihood is and are stepping up their efforts to protect it, especially now that finning for shark-fin soup is dropping shark numbers precipitously. Beqa Adventure Divers, a notable shark dive operator in Fiji, has been blogging about its efforts to get Discovery Channel to get the Jaws references out of its upcoming Shark Week series this summer. Andrew Cumming, Beqas operations manager, wrote on the shops blog (http://fijisharkdiving.blogspot.com) about the shady efforts of one of the networks film teams to hire Beqa to take them to dive sites but then do their own thing. We were told the group would come with their own safety divers, need a chumsicle and require no further service other than unlimited access to our site. Cumming believed the team leader was going to descend in a specially-designed clear shark cage and conduct experiments like flailing about, floating lifelessly and holding freshly-killed fish to elicit an attack response from the sharks. After years of trying to establish a safe and mellow routine and to keep the sharks away from the surface, having [them] come and thrash our dive site! We of course declined to enable the shoot. He said another dive shop down the road agreed to take the film crew out. Money apparently talks much louder than ones professed love of sharks and fake ecobranding. But in the end, its not our country, not our operation and hopefully, not our reputation, either, that will lose out. Although well have to share the negative repercussions, as will Fiji tourism. In the end, the real losers will be the sharks.

Abernethy is also stating his pro-shark stance to the public, becoming active in government actions on coral reefs and shark management. He recently protested a June shark tournament in Fort Myers, helping to get it turned into a no-kill event. On his Web site, he blogged about a seven-foot lemon shark with a rope tied around its neck cutting deep into its skin and gills. It swam off before Abernethy could free it. In April, he saw the shark again while taking a charter of photographers and videographers. They all agreed to rescue the shark, tail roping and pulling it aboard. Abernethy restrained the shark while a crew member cut the rope. In just over one minute, the shark was back in the water. The thought of this beautiful creature dying a slow painful death because of trash discarded in the ocean was too much for me, he wrote. Many people would think that its just a shark and not to bother, but I love these creatures and will do anything within my power to save them. Of course, when he saw the lemon shark the next day, Abernethy fed it lots of fish to keep it coming back.

- - Vanessa Richardson

P.S. The latest shark fatality of 2008 happened to a French woman on June 2, when an oceanic whitetip shark attacked her while snorkeling along Egypts Red Sea shoreline, south of Marsa Alam. The woman, in her 50s, was part of a group aboard the liveaboard Le Nautile. About 20 snorkelers were at the dive site Habili Al on the St. Johns reef area observing the shark when the woman moved away from the group and duckdived toward it. According to Egypts Chamber of Diving and Watersports (CWDS), the woman was bitten on the leg when she surfaced, and the shark was still biting her as she was pulled onto the boat. She lost consciousness and died soon after.

It was Egypts first fatal shark attack in five years; the previous one was another snorkeler near the busy Sinai resort of Sharm el-Sheikh in 2004. While such attacks are extremely rare in the Red Sea, this one most likely happened because two safari boats had been feeding sharks in the same area that day. Both the National Park and CDWS are conducting an investigation into the recent incident, CDWS spokeswoman Mary Gleeson told Undercurrent. Shark feeding is illegal here in the Red Sea. It is looking likely that they will face a serious fine and suspension from operating for a period of time, probably three months.

Ritter, who teaches some of his SharkSchool courses in the Red Sea, says dive boats there routinely flout the no-feeding rules. The galley staff dump leftovers after the cooking is done, and divers take fish with them after lunch and start feeding sharks. Every boat does this because divers want to push the envelope, so theyre forced to increase the thrill. Theyre competing for the few sharks left but they dont know how to handle an antsy, full-grown oceanic whitetip.

- -Vanessa Richardson

I want to get all the stories! Tell me how I can become an Undercurrent Online Member and get online access to all the articles of Undercurrent as well as thousands of first hand reports on dive operations world-wide



NEW! Find in  

| Home | Online Members Area | My Account |
| Travel Index | Dive Gear Index | Health/Safety Index | Environment & Misc. Index | Seasonal Planner | Forums | Blogs | Free Articles | Book Picks | News |
| Dive Resort & Liveaboard Reviews | Featured Reports | Recent Issues | Back Issues | Login | Join | Special Offers | RSS | FAQ | About Us | Contact Us | Links |


Copyright © 1996-2016 Undercurrent (www.undercurrent.org)
3020 Bridgeway, Ste 102, Sausalito, Ca 94965
All rights reserved.

fc