after much debate, we have decided to rent a car. We now have a few other peoiple with us so that helps with the cost. I looked into CHucho divers, and they look great, but we have decided to go with Living UNderwater. We really like using steel tanks, and Jeremy has been a lot of help so far. He says he does pick up at downtown pier after all, but not sure yet where we'll meet as we'll have the car now. LU is a little more expensive, but cheap accomodations/food help offset the cost of diving, as that is the main reason to be there!